Skip to main content
Drone Ranker

Fifteen States Sued the FAA Over Drone Delivery. The Fight Is One Document.

· Founder & Editor
11 Min Read
Fifteen States Sued the FAA Over Drone Delivery. The Fight Is One Document.

The FAA drone delivery lawsuit began on 28 September, when fifteen state attorneys general and one Texas county asked a federal appeals court to throw out a document most people have never heard of. It is not a rule about where drones may fly or how loud they may be. It is an environmental review, written once and applied to every commercial drone delivery hub in the United States.

Four days earlier, a federal judge in New Jersey struck down a borough’s drone ordinance as preempted by federal law, and then refused to give the pilot who challenged it anything at all.

Read together, the two filings explain why the states went after the paperwork rather than the flights. On who controls the airspace, they would lose. On whether the FAA did its homework before opening that airspace to delivery drones nationwide, they might not.

Update, 1 October 2026. The first operator to scale entirely inside that clearance is already here. DoorDash received its Part 135 air carrier certificate on 29 July, the day after the FAA signed the document, and unveiled its own delivery drone on 30 September. California, its planned launch state, is among the petitioners.

What the fifteen states filed in the FAA drone delivery lawsuit

The petition was lodged on 28 September in the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, with New York Attorney General Letitia James as counsel for the group. Joining her: California, Arizona, Colorado, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Washington and Wisconsin, together with Harris County, Texas.

They want three linked documents signed on 28 July 2026 set aside: the FAA’s final Programmatic Environmental Assessment for commercial drone package delivery, the Finding of No Significant Impact that followed from it, and the Record of Decision. The legal ground is the National Environmental Policy Act. The remedy asked for is vacatur, meaning removal of the document, not a pause. Filing a petition for review does not suspend the decision, so deliveries continue while the case runs unless a court orders otherwise.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office put the complaint plainly: the assessment “does not adequately address the potential safety risks or other environmental impacts” of the expansion it contemplates, and says too little about the communities underneath it.

The timing was deliberate. The window to challenge the July decision closed on Saturday 26 September. Under the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure a deadline falling on a weekend moves to the next business day, which is how the petition came to be filed on the last possible Monday.

The number the whole clearance rests on

Before 28 July, a company that wanted to start drone delivery in a new city generally needed an environmental assessment for that city. A programmatic assessment is written once for a whole class of future actions, so projects that fit inside its limits don’t each need their own review. This one covers commercial package delivery under Part 135 by any operator, from hubs anywhere in the United States, Alaska and Hawaii included, to delivery locations anywhere in the country.

It is not unlimited. Its scope is set by one figure.

“The proposed action includes a UCT of 1,150 AAD deliveries from a single hub.” (FAA, Final Programmatic Environmental Assessment)

UCT is the unit capacity threshold. AAD is average annual day: the year’s total deliveries divided by 365. Stay under 1,150 a day from one hub and the operation sits inside the national document, with no site-specific environmental analysis. Go above it and, in the FAA’s words, “a more detailed analysis specific to the proposed activity would be required to evaluate the potential for noise impacts”, unless the operator can show its aircraft would be no louder than the noise profile the threshold was built on.

The rest of the envelope is just as specific. Hubs must sit at least 183 meters (600 feet) from noise-sensitive land uses, a setback the final version made binding rather than recommended. Cruise runs between 46 and 114 meters (150 to 375 feet), under a 122-meter (400-foot) ceiling. Aircraft plus package may not exceed 50 kilograms (110 pounds).

Now put 1,150 next to the largest single request pending. Amazon has asked to fly up to 1,000 MK30 flights a day from a warehouse in North Haven, Connecticut, over a 7.5-mile radius, from 6 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. The two numbers aren’t measured the same way (the FAA’s is an annual average, Amazon’s a daily maximum), so they can’t be compared cleanly.

But they are close enough that the threshold is no longer a theoretical ceiling. A real filing is being drawn up against it. And those flights end the way every Amazon delivery ends, by releasing the parcel in mid-air from about thirteen feet, which ten states already have statutes about.

FAA drone delivery lawsuit timeline: from the draft programmatic environmental assessment in December 2025 to the fifteen-state petition on 28 September 2026 and the October deadlines in Connecticut and Massachusetts

They said all of this in writing, and the FAA published anyway

The petition is not a new argument. It is an old one moved to a courtroom.

The FAA put the draft assessment out in December 2025 and took 241 comments, with the window extended into late January at the public’s request. Seventeen attorneys general and Harris County filed against it then, calling the draft “a paper exercise, largely devoid of reliable qualitative or quantitative analyses.”

Two objections sit underneath that phrase. The first is noise: the model measured delivery drones against aviation baselines alone, leaving out the road and rail noise a suburban street already lives with, which flatters the result. The second is fire. The states pointed to an incident in Tolleson, Arizona in October 2025, in which an Amazon MK30’s battery was ejected in a collision and burned, and argued the lithium-battery analysis did not take that class of risk seriously.

The FAA answered commenters in an appendix and kept its numbers. The one change between draft and final was that hub setbacks became a condition instead of a request. Everything else, including the 1,150 threshold, survived. That is the decision now before the Second Circuit.

Two of the seventeen did not sign

Seventeen states objected during the comment round. Fifteen signed the petition. Neither of the other two, Connecticut and Vermont, has said why.

Connecticut is the more conspicuous absence, because the biggest pending hub request in the country sits there. It is also running a parallel process of its own. The Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP) is conducting a coastal consistency review of the North Haven proposal: public comment closes on 1 October and DEEP must give the FAA its answer by 16 October. That review can produce a concurrence or an objection. It cannot set altitudes, hours or noise limits; it asks only whether the federal action fits the state’s coastal policies.

Nobody has said publicly whether those two facts are connected, and I won’t assume they are. What can be said is narrower: the state with the most immediate exposure to this clearance is fighting it through a state permit process rather than a federal court.

Low aerial view of a residential street of single-family houses, illustrating the local airspace a municipal drone ordinance tries to regulate
A town cannot close the airspace over its own streets. Photo: @aviosly / Unsplash.

Why nobody is arguing about authority any more

On 24 September, in a letter opinion in Palange v. Borough of Lodi (2:26-cv-02375, District of New Jersey), Judge Susan D. Wigenton showed why a case like the states’ gets filed the way it does.

Lodi adopted Chapter 217 in June 2025. It banned camera-carrying drones below 400 feet anywhere in the borough, and sensor-free aircraft below 400 feet over residential and commercial zones, roads and public buildings. A third offense carried up to $2,000 and 90 days. Paul Palange, who represented himself, flew a camera-free drone from his own yard and collected three summonses in July 2025.

The court found the ordinance both field preempted and conflict preempted. The reasoning is short: the FAA caps most small drone flight at 400 feet, Lodi prohibited flight below 400 feet, and together that left “no meaningful altitude band in which a UAS may lawfully operate.” The ordinance stood as “an obstacle to the FAA and Congress’s objectives to integrate UAS into the national airspace.”

And then Palange got nothing. The borough told the court his FAA-compliant flights were already permitted and that it was not enforcing the ordinance against him. That made his injury speculative rather than imminent, and the restraining order was denied. He won the point and left without a remedy.

That is the backdrop to the state petition. A local government writing its own airspace rule loses on the law, and fifteen attorneys general did not file a preemption case. What is left is procedure: not whether the FAA may open the airspace, but whether it followed the statute on the way.

The next two weeks

The court case will take months. The decisions that put drones over particular streets are being made now.

  • 1 October: Connecticut DEEP’s public comment window on North Haven closes. Comments are weighed against coastal policy, so the ones that count address coastal resources rather than noise preferences.
  • 1 October: Westborough, Massachusetts holds a Select Board special meeting on the hub proposed at 64 Otis Street: roughly six MK30s, a 7.5-mile radius, several hundred deliveries a day, possibly flying by the end of October.
  • 6 October: the Westborough planning board hears the site plan application.
  • 16 October: Connecticut must return its consistency answer to the FAA.

Massachusetts is doing both things at once. It signed the federal petition on 28 September, and on 29 September three of its state legislators, Senator Michael Moore, Representative Kate Donaghue and Representative Hannah Kane, asked Amazon to pause the Westborough launch until it answered on operating hours, flight paths, service range and daily flight counts. A local survey put opposition at 92 percent. It was a community survey, not a scientific poll, so read it as a measure of who turned up, not of the town.

None of this has slowed Amazon elsewhere: the company opened in Cleveland this month and is still working toward nearly 500 US cities and towns. A spokesman said Amazon is working with local officials to bring the service to the area, and the company has said fewer than one percent of customer contacts mention noise.

What this changes if you just fly a drone

Directly, nothing. The lawsuit concerns commercial package delivery under Part 135. It has no bearing on Part 107 work or recreational flying, and no drone becomes more or less legal to own because of it.

The Lodi opinion is the half that reaches ordinary pilots, but keep its weight in proportion. It is a district court ruling on a request for a temporary restraining order and binds nobody outside that case. Still, it is one more reasoned holding that a municipal ban on flight below 400 feet cannot stand. A town can still regulate what happens on ground it owns, such as takeoff and landing in municipal parks; it is airspace rules that run into preemption. Local rules vary, and this is not legal advice.

If the Second Circuit vacates the assessment, the FAA has to do the analysis again. That would slow expansion into new markets. It would not make delivery drones illegal, and what happens to approvals already granted under the document would be for the court and the agency to sort out.

This is the strongest card the states have, and possibly the only one. A week ago it was unclear whether states could do anything about drone delivery. The question is still open, but it has narrowed to one document, and it now has a court, a docket and a calendar.

Want to fly one yourself?

DJI Neo

135 g, palm takeoff, no controller needed. Under 250 g: recreational flyers skip FAA registration but still need TRUST.

Check on Amazon →

DJI Mini 4K

Under 249 g, 3-axis gimbal, 4K/30. The cheapest DJI camera drone with a real gimbal.

Check on Amazon →

As an Amazon Associate, Drone Ranker earns from qualifying purchases. We do not quote prices because Amazon’s change by the hour.

The Friday Brief

One email a week on what changed in drones

FCC and FAA rule changes, DJI leaks checked against filings, and the week’s new comparisons. Every Friday, nothing else.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Sent with Kit; see our privacy policy.

Follow us on Google too: add Drone Ranker as a preferred source →

All News